The 12 Best Down Alternative Comforters

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Using a high-quality comforter during the night is one of the key contributors to getting a good night’s rest. But if you’ve been using the same comforter for a long period of time, it’s likely that your comforter is less fluffy and plush than it used to be. In fact, it isn’t uncommon for most comforters on the market to not be able to keep their quality consistent throughout long-term use. Especially if a comforter isn’t machine-washable, it can be quite a difficult task to make it feel like its brand new over an extended period of time.

    In order to ensure you get a quality sleep night after night, it’s crucial that you invest in the right comforter for you that will provide unmatched softness as well as a durable use, no matter the sleeping conditions. Well, everybody dreams of sleeping on clouds because of their fluffy nature but it is almost impossible. With a down alternative comforter, you can get the perfect product that meets your needs at an affordable price that comes with a quality finish.

    Down alternative comforters are made of synthetic materials that are designed to replicate the fill and properties of natural down. Some of the materials used in this make include cotton, rayon, and polyester fibers. Down alternative comforters are known for providing the perfect blend of warmth and comfort throughout each blanket comforter that uses this material. 

    These comforters are also great for those with allergies, because of their natural and synthetic materials used in production. These cruelty-free comforters are a great option for you if you’re prone to allergies while also looking for an affordable pick.

    From a goose down comforter to wool down alternative comforters, you can find a variety of these comforters in target with your wants and needs. In order to find the best options for you, we’ve sorted through reviews to help simplify the process of getting your perfect fit!

    1. PlushBeds Down Alternative Mattress Topper

    Kicking off our list of best down alternative comforters is this mattress topper from PlushBeds. This alternative down comforter ensures that you have a deep and restful sleep throughout the night. Featuring 3″ of plush and a hypoallergenic down alternative fill, this topper is encased in pure cotton which makes it both breathable and cozy. The baffle-box construction of this topper prevents the inner filling from shifting and ensures that this mattress topper has an even loft.

    Baffle box construction means that the shell is sewn in stitched squares, or pockets, resulting in an airy and fluffy fill. Besides this baffle box construction, this product also comprises of elastic anchor bands for securing the fiber bed to the mattress. It’s also machine-washable so you can keep this comforter clean just by tossing it into the washing machine.

    Key Features

    • Down alternative fill
    • Features 100% cotton shell
    • Has baffle-box construction
    • 3″ thick plush
    • Has corner anchor bands to secure fiber bed to the mattress

    Benefits

    • Shell is breathable
    • Free of odors and allergens
    • The inner fill doesn’t shift
    • Even loft
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Machine-washable

    2. Parachute Down Alternative Duvet Insert

    If you want your bed to feel comfortable and high-quality, then this down alternative duvet insert is the best choice for you. It’s filled with a hypoallergenic microfiber fill that makes this down alternative insert fluffy and gives it an insulating quality. 

    This product from Parachute Home also features soft sateen that is sewn around the fill in the box construction to keep it evenly distributed. It is also equipped with sturdy and double-stitched seams. This duvet insert is also machine-washable and can be easily kept clean by using mild liquid laundry detergent.

    Also, you can tumble dry low using dryer balls. If you look at any review of this product, it seems like it may be a good quality product to invest in. With this lightweight option, you can keep cool while you sleep and you may feel more comfortable than ever before. It’s worth the investment if you may earn a good night’s sleep in return If you find that you get cold throughout the night, you’ll be sure to like this product and get the most of it year-round.

    Key Features

    • Filled with microfiber
    • Made in Ohio
    • Shell is made from 100% cambric cotton
    • Finished with double-stitched and sturdy seams
    • Machine-washable

    Benefits

    • Hypoallergenic
    • Soft
    • Easy to wash
    • Will keep you warm and cozy

    3. L.L.Bean PrimaLoft Down Alternative Comforter

    If you are looking for a hypoallergenic, cozy, fluffy, and soft down alternative comforter without paying a high price, then this L.L. Bean PrimaLoft Down Alternative Comforter is the best choice for you. This product is possibly the best lightweight comforter out of all of the ones on our roster. The comforter has a low weight to it so that you feel like you aren’t weighed down while you sleep. This product is also filled with hypoallergenic polyester microfiber material, so those who are allergy-prone will like that they can use it without having sensitivities.

    The box-stitch construction of this comforter prevents the fill from shifting so that there are no cold spots, making it able to consistently provide warmth even in cold winter nights. Included with this comforter is a soft cover that features a 280 thread count. While most high-quality covers feature a 300 thread count cotton material, this 280 count cover from L.L. Bean will feel just as good.

    You can easily maintain this best down alternative comforter as it is machine-washable, making it easy to keep it clean. While it’s easy to wash, be sure to follow the care instructions for the best results. This product features also corner loops that can be attached to the cotton cover of the comforter so that both the cover and comforter keep in their place. This comforter is ideal for sleepers who consistently toss and turn in their sleep.

    Key Features

    • Available in twin, full, queen, and king sizes
    • Features box stitching
    • USA-made
    • Made from imported and USA-based materials
    • Features corner loop construction
    • Comes with a storage bag

    Benefits

    • Warm and fluffy feel
    • Box-stitching construction
    • Best for year-round use as it provides warmth and is breathable
    • Budget-friendly

    4. The Buffy Breeze Comforter

    The Buffy Breeze comforter features a soft and rights reserved Oeko-Tex certified eucalyptus shell and fill which will keep you warm and cozy while you sleep. The best thing about these eucalyptus-made alternative down comforters is that they will never overheat you. As compared to the alternative comforters with a goose down or polyester fill, this buffy pick does not trap heat which is perfect for those who sleep hot.

    The eucalyptus used in making this best goose down alternative comforter is grown using 10x less water as compared to other materials. This lightweight comforter is also resistant to dust mites and mold, allowing you to sleep soundly knowing your health is not at risk. While this goose down alternative comforter from buffy is machine-washable, it’s recommended that you dry clean it for best results. Buffy also offers a cloud pillow that is a great choice for completing your bedtime essentials. Read the full review of the Buffy Cloud Pillow here.

    Key Features

    • Comes with Oeko-Tex certified eucalyptus shell and fiber
    • Sewn with 100% recycled thread
    • Comes in twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, or California king size
    • Features wave stitching pattern
    • Machine-washable

    Benefits

    • It is breathable and cool
    • Provides warmth and cozy sleep without overheating
    • Resistant to dust mites and mold
    • Lightweight and cool-to-touch

    5. Leesa Duvet Insert

    This duvet insert from Leesa is made from a 100% organic shell. This is a soft, comfortable, and breathable comforter that will keep you warm and cozy during the cold nights of winter. If you find that many of the comforters you’ve used in the past require too much to take care of it, that’s one of the many benefits to this product. This insert is not only light in weight, but it is also machine-washable. While it’s easy to wash, be sure to follow the care instructions for the best results.

    There are two corner ties on the top of this comforter and two on the bottom, and they both work to ensure that it stays in place and provides you with year-round comfort. This comforter is full of a 100% polyester fill in each size that it comes with including twin size, twin XL size, full size, queen size, king size, and California king size. 

    This product may be the best fit for you if you like lightweight, cozy comforters that keep you super comfortable throughout your sleep. Leesa also offers a high-quality mattress that is a great addition to your bedtime essentials. Read our full review of the Leesa Mattress here.

    Key Features

    • Made from 100% organic cotton shell
    • Machine washable
    • Comes with two corner ties on top and two corner ties on the bottom
    • 100% polyester fill

    Benefits

    • Soft, fluffy and comfortable
    • Breathable
    • Durable materials for year-round use and will last a long time
    • Will keep you warm during the night
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Will always stay in its place

    This goose down alternative comforter from Snowe has all the features that a regular goose down alternative comforter has but the difference is that it comes with the plushest and most fluffy microfiber fill. This alternative comforter is allergen-free and consists of loops on all of the four corners that make sure that the duvet cover stays in place.

    The best thing about this alternative comforter is that it is available in a light weight choice, that is ideal for people who like to sleep warm, and the All-Season choice is great for year-round comfort and is ideal for people who feel cold at night. One of the many benefits that this has to offer is that it has durable stitching so it will be long-lasting. This goose down alternative product is also machine-washable, making it easy to keep it in super good condition.

    Key Features

    • Comes in light weight and All-Season choice which is great for year-round comfort
    • Features microfiber fill
    • Has two loops on top and two loops on the bottom
    • The USA-made product
    • Available in 2 different sizes in each option
    • All-Season option features 40% more fill than the light weight category
    • Comes with 330 thread count cotton cover

    Benefits

    • Breathable
    • Allergen-free
    • Minimum heat retention
    • Super soft and fluffy
    • It’s able to be cleaned in the washing machine
    • Ideal for all seasons
    • Fluffy weight to it

    7. LINENSPA All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Comforter

    This All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Comforter is considered to be one of the best down alternative comforters. This alternative comforter consists of a hypoallergenic and ultra-soft goose down alternative microfiber fill which makes it best suited for people who are suffering from allergies or other sensitivities. This is a versatile comforter that is suitable for all seasons. 

    The best thing about this alternative comforter is that if you want to give your bedroom decor a new look then you can either flip it or slip it in a duvet cover. Moreover, this alternative comforter is available in various neutral color options. One of the many benefits that this has to offer is that it has durable stitching so it will be long-lasting.

    The sewn corners and side loops allow you to easily add a duvet cover to this comforter as it has eight points instead of four. It also features box stitching that prevents fill from shifting and gives it a smooth look. This goose down product is offered in many sizes, including twin, twin XL, queen, full, oversized queen, king, oversized king, and a king California size. This wide range of options allows customers to get the proper size they need to sleep with and get the best comforter for them. For best results, measure your mattress before purchase.

    Key Features

    • Available in different color options
    • Features ultra-soft alternative microfiber fill
    • Features box-stitching
    • Machine washable
    • Available in twin, twin XL, queen, full, oversized queen, king, California king, and oversize king sizes
    • Ideal for all seasons

    Benefits

    • Extremely lightweight
    • Hypoallergenic
    • The duvet cover can be easily added
    • Super fluffy and soft
    • It will keep you warm
    • It’s able to be cleaned in the washing machine
    • Fluffy weight to it

    8. AllerEase Hot Water Washable Allergy Protection Comforter

    If you suffer from and want a comforter that blocks dust mites, allergens and provides maximum allergy protection, then AllerEase Hot Water Washable Allergy Protection Comforter is the best option for you. This best alternative comforter is made from a blend of 65% polyester and 35% cotton and features a hypoallergenic fiberfill. A lot of the time, comforters with weak stitching require too much and too careful of a care process to them. With the durable stitching of this product, it will not bunch up after washing and drying.

    This alternative comforter has a low weight to it like its filled with feathers as well as warm and will prove to be a great addition to your bedroom accessories no matter what season it is. This comforter features a box-quilted design that adds extra comfort and warmth. The fabric is extremely soft to touch. 

    Something that makes this comforter a great choice out of the many on the market is that it can stand the test of time since it’s made from durable materials. You can easily clean it by washing it in hot water to remove the germs and bacteria. The best thing about it is that its fill will never shift after you wash or dry it.

    Key Features

    • Made from a blend of 65% polyester and 35% cotton
    • Features a hypoallergenic fiberfill
    • Has box-quilted design
    • Washable with hot water
    • Backed by a 5-year limited warranty

    Benefits

    • 100% allergy-proof
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Easy to clean
    • Lightweight and warm
    • Fluffy weight to it
    • Blocks dust mites

    9. Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert

    Want to enjoy a heavenly sleeping experience then this then Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert is ideal for you. It is a soft and fluffy alternative comforter with a fiber-fill that will keep you warm and cozy. This alternative comforter is similar to a duvet and fits snugly in a duvet cover. By adding a duvet cover to this you can easily change the look of your bedroom without having it redecorated. 

    This alternative comforter features a box stitching quilting design that provides you with maximum warmth, which is not too much for those who like to sleep cool. One of the many benefits that this has to offer is that it has durable stitching so it will be long-lasting.

    This one of the best down alternative comforters that uses classic box pattern design paired with sturdy piped edges that create a wall between the top and bottom layers and prevents polyester filling from getting shifted or bunched up. Since it’s filled with polyester, this product is ideal for those that want a comforter and fluffy option that will keep them comfortable. 

    Something that makes this comforter a great choice out of the many on the market is that it can stand the test of time since it’s made from durable materials. The piping on the seams enhances the durability of this comforter. So in short of you want to enjoy a heavily sleeping experience then there s no better goose down alternative comforter than this one.

    Key Features

    • Measures 88″ x 88″
    • Piped edges
    • Consists of two corner tabs on the top and two corner tabs on the bottom
    • Machine washable
    • Features a fiber-fill
    • Uses the classic box pattern design

    Benefits

    • Fits snugly in a duvet cover
    • Durable
    • Easy to clean and wash
    • The fill won’t shift or clump

    10. All-Season Down Alternative Comforter

    Give your bed a warm and cozy look with this All-Season goose down alternative comforter. This alternative comforter features a baffle box and double-stitched design for year-round comfort. This alternative comforter features stitching on top as well as the bottom of the comforter that prevents cold areas by creating firmly sewn pockets.

    This comforter features a hypoallergenic goose down alternative polyester fill that will neither shift nor clump after washing and drying. Moreover, it is easy to clean as it supports machine wash. This comforter has dual functions as you can use it on its own or you can use it as a duvet insert. Overall, this a highly durable, well-made, and over-sized comforter.

    Key Features

    • Features a down alternative polyester fill
    • The material used for the cover is microfiber
    • Features Baffle box stitching
    • Available in twin XL, king, full and queen size
    • Also supports machine wash

    Benefits

    • Provides you with year-round comfort
    • Fluffy weight to it
    • The weight of this comforter is just perfect
    • It fills the duvet cover perfectly
    • It stretches from end to end

    11. Midweight All-Season Microfiber Down Alternative Comforter

    This mid-weight down alternative comforter is considered to be an ideal choice for staying warm all night. With this amazing goose down alternative comforter, you can add warmth to your bed by giving it a comfy and cozy look. This comforter perfectly fits any duvet cover. 

    This mid-weight down alternative comforter is made up of microfiber and features box stitch design that gives it a classic look and prevents the fill from shifting. Moreover, this comforter is also breathable making it comfortable at night. As far as washing is concerned, you just have to give it a quick cycle in the washing machine and it will look good as new.

    Key Features

    • Made up of microfiber
    • Features box-stitch construction
    • Supports machine wash
    • It comprises of sewn corner tabs
    • Consists of a hypoallergenic down alternative fill
    • Available in 8 different sizes

    Benefits

    • The box-stitching does not allow the fill to shift
    • You can use it in all the seasons
    • It is extremely soft and easy to clean
    • It is designed to keep your body temperature even during the night
    • Fluffy weight to it

    12. Alwyn Home All-Season Microfiber Down Alternative Comforter

    Give your bedroom a beautiful and lively look with this all-season microfiber down alternative comforter. This alternative comforter is made up of 100% microfiber and is naturally hypoallergenic. Moreover, its baffle-box construction gives this comforter a modern and contemporary look. 

    This alternative comforter is cozy and also machine washable. This beautiful and charming down alternative comforter can be paired with a mattress dressed in white sheets, quatrefoil accent pillows, and hand-crocheted throw.

    Key Features

    • Features baffle-box construction
    • Made from 100% microfiber

    Benefits

    • It is lightweight and cruelty-free
    • Naturally hypoallergenic
    • Extremely soft to touch
    • Well-made
    • Fluffy weight to it

    Buyer's Guide

    When it comes to investing in any product, it is necessary to review it before you make the purchase. In order to make sure you get the best bang for you’re buck, we’ve provided the ins and outs of the best down alternative comforters so you can pick the best option for you.

    The Benefits of Down Alternative Comforters

    From their easy upkeep to their hypoallergenic properties, there are great benefits from switching to a down alternative comforter that reviewers across the Internet would agree with. These benefits include:

    Easy Care

    Down is a very fragile material, and if you don’t take good care of it, then it may get damaged easily and fail to last the test of time. Luckily, this is not the case with down alternative comforters. These types of comforters are both easy to wash and easy to store. You can easily take care of this machine-washable product so that it keeps its softness and high-quality nature over time.

    Allergy-Friendly

    If you tend to wake up in the morning sneezing and coughing, it may be due to the comforter that you sleep with. The type of materials used in the production of a comforter can mean the difference between waking up allergy-free or waking up with even worse allergies than you’d typically have. However, down alternative comforters contain hypoallergenic materials that allergy-prone people are sure to love.

    Affordable Price

    Because down is one of the more high-quality materials, it typically comes with a high price tag. As the quality of down increases, so does the price. Fortunately, down alternative comforters are less expensive than down comforters, making them a great pick for those looking to stay in their budget.

    The Drawbacks of Down Alternative Comforters

    With any product on the market, there are bound to be a few drawbacks to the product. After sorting through reviews, we’ve found that while there are few cons to this type of comforter, there are a couple to take note of before you make your purchase. These include:

    Warmth

    Natural down products offer incredible warmth that a normal comforter likely won’t be able to provide. This ensures that you stay cozy during any winter temperature, making you sleep comfortably throughout the night without being too hot. When it comes to a down alternative comfort, the level of warmth it provides may not be up to the level that a down comforter offers. You will likely still However, the down alternative comforters are filled with heavy material to make you warm.

    Hefty Filling

    A drawback in a comforter having a down alternative fill instead of a down fill is that the more filling it has, the heavier the comforter becomes. With that being said, if you’re looking for a light-weight, breathable comforter, this type of comforter may not be ideal for your needs. However, if you’re looking for one that will keep you cozy in cold weather, you may want to keep a down alternative comforter in mind.

    The Fill Material

    Typically, the fill material used in down alternative comforters is synthetic but it also includes other materials as well. The following are the most common fill materials used in down alternative comforters:

    Polyester

    This fill material is the most common product used in the best comforters out there. Polyester is a flexible material that is produced to have different weights and lofts so each comforter varies in style. Polyester is a material that is produced at a very low cost as compared to down, making these types of comforters typically an affordablechoice. Usually, the polyester used for making these products is soft, light, and lofty, which helps in providing warmth during every cold, winter night.

    Primaloft

    This next material that brands fill the best down alternative comforters with is considered to be a high-quality product that makes for a light and fluffy comforter. Primaloft is a high-end synthetic fabric that has the same performance quality of a down comforter at a more affordable price. This material has a lightweight feel that may suit sleepers who like sleeping in a cooler temperature, without becoming too hot while they sleep. Primaloft is also water-resistant and doesn’t lose its loft, even after you get it wet.

    Gel Fiber

    Another type of material used in these budget-friendly comforters is gel-fiber. This type of material is capable of retaining heat, making it a great choice for cooler temperatures in the winter. Even if you don’t prefer to sleep hot, this material in a blanket is fluffy and will still provide you with the perfect amount of fluffiness you need to sleep well.

    Non-Down Fill Materials

    Some of the non-down fill materials used in down alternative comforters are:

    Silk

    While most down alternative comforters are available at affordable prices, a silk-made product may cause the price tag to be higher than others. Similar to down, silk is another light material that’s perfect for hot sleepers. This type of material is ideal for those seeking a luxurious sleeping experience and those that are willing to pay the higher price for the higher quality. However, something that might be a downside to some people is that silk materials do not have as strong of an insulating power as down.

    Cotton

    If you want a comforter that remains close to or within your budget, a blanket with a cotton filling may be your best bet. This material is a cost-efficient and soft material that offers a good night’s sleep at an affordable cost. Down comforters that use this fill material have limited insulating power, but still, they are comfortable and may be a blanket that you love.

    Wool

    Despite comforters filled with wool being heavy, this fabric is a breathable product. This material provides a sufficient amount of insulation and also it dissipates heat and wicks away moisture during the summer season when you may feel too much warmth. These comforters may be a good fit for you if you’re looking for a blanket that feels super comforting but allows you to sleep cool.

    Fill Power

    The term fill power is used to refer to the volume or amount of space that 1 ounce of the down takes up. The higher the fill power is, the more warmth the comforter will offer. Usually, this term is not used with down alternative comforters but in some cases, it is used to indicate the expected heat potential of the comforter. These temperatures include:

    Below 400

    Fill power below 400 indicates that the comforter delivers a limited amount of heat. These comforters are usually used by pairing them with other blankets and are typically a great product for warmer temperatures.

    400 to 599

    The comforters with a fill power ranging from 400-599 are not suitable for all seasons as they don’t provide enough warmth during winters. A comforter with this fill power is usually used by layering it with another blanket in order for you to feel warm and cozy throughout your sleep during the night.

    600 to 799

    Comforters with a fill power with 600-799 have considerable warmth to the product. If you tend to sleep cold at night, then a comforter in this a 750 fill power may prove to be the best fit for your sleep at night. A comforter with a 750 fill power of a 750 fill will help you feel like you’re warm and cozy, even in the coldest winter nights.

    More than 800

    Comforters with a fill power of more than 800 feel like a heavy winter blanket. Such comforters are lofty and have high-quality insulation so they may not be fit for warmer temperatures.

    Shell Material

    The outer fabric that surrounds the comforter is known to be the shell of the comforter. There are several materials such as a cotton shell or a silk shell that are used in these products. The following are some of the common materials used for making the shell of the down alternative comforter:

    Cotton Shell

    A cotton shell is a very popular material know for its use in consumer textiles. As far as its quality is concerned, it has a lot of range but it is soft, cost-efficient, and easy to wash. The breathability of cotton depends upon its thickness. In general, cotton is known for absorbing moisture but it may heat up more than other materials.

    Silk Shell

    Silk is known for its softness. While silk is a more expensive choice than others, it’s worth the price as it is cool to the touch and does not retain heat. One downside of a silk shell is that it is difficult to clean without damaging the product. Alternative to down comforter, silk is not typically used for down comforter alternatives which is why most of these products are affordable.

    Synthetic and Blends

    Synthetic materials are not only used in the fill of down alternative comforters but are also used in making the shell of alternative down comforters. Synthetic materials are breathable, soft, and flexible. Also, synthetic materials are blended with cotton to provide more softness.

    Wool

    Wool is a material that comes from sheep and is breathable while providing a great deal of warmth while you sleep. Usually, this fill is woven to deliver significant softness to each sleeper so they can rest comfortably throughout the night. Because of its cost, this material is not usually found as shell material for down alternative comforters.

    FAQ

    Most frequent down alternative comforter questions

    The best down alternative comforter is the one that offers superior warmth, is hypoallergenic, is easy to maintain, is suitable for all seasons, is soft to touch, and most importantly it is breathable.

    To choose an alternative down comforter you should consider its fill material, fabric, warmth it offers, thread count, and its size.

    As far as the material is concerned, there are 5 best materials fro comforters which are cotton, wool, silk, down, and bamboo. However, amongst all these bamboo is considered to be the best as it is breathable, soft, and retains warmth.

    Conclusion

    With a down alternative comforter, you can experience the same level of warmth that is offered by a 100% down comforter along with all other benefits down comforter offers. The animal-free fill material used in down alternative comforters does not trigger allergies or other sensitivities that are triggered by down comforters that use materials from goose or duck sources. If you like the feel of comforters that use feathers, you’ll likely prefer these products once you’ve felt the comfort the feathers provide.

    As compared to down comforters it is also budget-friendly. This means you can enjoy the warmth on your bed and live comfortably without breaking your budget. So from the above-given list of best down alternative comforters based on thousands of reviews, you can easily select the down alternative comforter that suits your needs!

    Share on twitter
    Twitter
    Share on pinterest
    Pinterest
    Share on facebook
    Facebook
    Share on reddit
    Reddit
    Share on email
    Email

    Leave a Comment